We are approaching the year end and soon the experts will start coming out with their predictions for next year. As there is a lot of competition to be the first one, I decided to get ahead in the line by kicking it off in November itself
So here goes
1. Barring any macro-economic shocks and if sensex earnings exceed 15%, the stock market should be up next year. If however we have a crisis in Europe or we get an oil shock then the index could even touch 10000 levels.
2. Gold could be up by 10%, if we get a major recession in US due to the fiscal cliff and it could surprise us on the upside if it coincides with the further instability in Greece and Spain. Over the long term, the macro-economic and supply-demand drivers point to a continued increase in gold prices.
3. Capital good stocks in India could surprise on the upside if the current momentum on the reforms continue. One needs to focus on high quality names in the sector
4. The consumption story continues to play out and high quality names should outperform the market in 2013, barring any sudden depreciation of the rupee. Demand from consumption centers, such as India and China largely seem to be on a firm footing
5. The real estate market will continue to face headwinds of high interest rates in the initial part of the year, but if RBI starts cutting rates in the second half, we could see higher activity in certain pockets of the market
6. Rohit Chauhan will become the smartest and richest investor in the Indian stock markets. President Obama and other world leaders will seek his counsel on how to fix the developed economies J
If facts change, do you change your mind?
I have often ‘preached’ on this blog – when facts change, one should consider them rationally and change one’s mind if required. Well, as always, it is easier to preach than practice.
Q4 sales growth, YOY – 60%
Net profit growth, YOY – 73% (12 Crs profit in Q4 versus 11 crs loss in Q3)
The explanation
It is easy to call the decision, stupid and move on. The true reason for my failure to capitalize on the change in performance (which I was expecting) is due to a behavioral bias.
Not a one off case
The above incident was not a one off in my case. I have made the same mistake twice earlier – in the case of VST industries and Mayur uniquoters. I sold the stocks and then saw the fundamental performance improve, after the sale. Instead to getting back into the stocks (as I already knew about the companies), I just ignored them and lost out on pretty decent gains.
I have become alert to this bias now and am paying more attention to sudden turning points in the performance of the stocks I hold or have held in the past.
It is better to look foolish (in my own eyes), than miss out on a good idea
Added note – The above example does not mean Ricoh India is a good buy and should be purchased at the current price. It is quite possible that the performance may regress and so would the stock price. The example is only for illustrative purposes.
Stocks discussed in this post are for educational purpose only and not recommendations to buy or sell. Please read disclaimer towards the end of blog.
A speculative bet
Stocks discussed in this post are for educational purpose only and not recommendations to buy or sell. Please read disclaimer towards the end of blog.
The return of the stock picker
Evaluating the impact of rupee depreciation
If the risks are too high (even if not quantifiable), then one should consider reducing the position size even if it results in a loss
Stocks discussed in this post are for educational purpose only and not recommendations to buy or sell. Please read disclaimer towards the end of blog
A few contrarian thoughts
Stocks discussed in this post are for educational purpose only and not recommendations to buy or sell. Please read disclaimer towards the end of blog.
It’s all warm, sunny and bubbly
Happy days are here again ! The index is at 20400 and will soon touch 22000 and then maybe 25000 or even 30000. The sky is the limit with India growing at 9%, and with a young population and all the other great factors working in its favor.
2008 was actually just a small bump on the way and the smart folks who bought during the downturn have made several times their investment. So the smart thing to do now is to load up on the small caps and midcaps as they have returned 100%+ returns in the last 2 years.
All the news channels are buzzing with hot new stocks and the smart thing to do is to watch these programs for tips and buy these stocks the next morning. The other day all those stock gurus and pundits were saying that now is the best time to buy as India has such a bright future ahead of it.
One should hold these stocks for a couple of days and sell it for a quick 10% profit. One only needs to do this a few times a year to make more than 100% on his or her investment. Actually, if you are really bullish, you should take on debt and dabble in options. Then the upside is unlimited and one should be able to retire in the next few months.
The problem with the news channel is that they don’t give the hottest tips. To get the hottest tips, one should join a penny stock service and use those tips to ‘play’ market. There is no time to waste on analyzing companies as most of these opportunities are available only for a short time and anyway who is planning to hold for more than a couple days ? So why bother !
It really does not matter that the IT stocks did badly after the 2000 bubble or the real estate stocks crashed in 2008. It is different this time!!!
Now is the time to get all excited and one should be fully invested, so that you don’t miss the opportunity of a lifetime. Heck, all my friends are making money and now my milkman and dhobi is in the market too!!
Note: If you are new to the blog, I hope you have realized that this is a sarcastic post and the exact opposite of my views.
Keeping papers in order
This is going to be a fairly odd and short post. I am going to discuss a topic which is not a fun topic, but nonetheless important.
Are your papers in order?
God forbid, if something were to happen to you tomorrow – does your family know the financial situation and has access to all the documentation?
I have heard of a lot of stories and personally encountered some, where the head of the family died and the heirs realized that the paperwork was a mess. I cannot tell you how painful it is to sort such matters.
So, I would suggest each one on us should atleast do the following
· Make a will
· Please add nominee in all your accounts – bank accounts, demats, FD etc
· Have a term insurance which pays in the unfortunate event of your death
· List all your accounts details on a piece of paper, make two copies with one in possession of a close family member and the other one in a locker
· Consolidate your provident fund with your current company – I repeat, please do this now! Getting provident fund issues sorted is a nightmare especially if they are old issues.
· File all the paperwork properly and update it atleast once a year.
I am myself partly guilty on not following all of the above. However I am continuously trying to ensure that my paperwork is in order and plan to clean it up further in the next 1-2 years.
You may be the next warren buffett or Rakesh jhunjhunwala or whatever you are dreaming of, but if your paper work is a mess, your family is going to suffer. The last thing you want is for your family to suffer due to the paperwork in addition to the emotional problems.
Cooling your enthusiasm
The previous post had some questions on how to handle over-optimism on a stock, especially when one is analyzing it for the first time.
I think it is human nature to be over-optimistic during bull markets and pessimistic during the bear phase. Even if you think you are immune to it, I personally think there is some impact of the surrounding environment. I have seen in my case that my fair value estimates are on the lower side when the market is dropping (being too conservative) and on the higher side when the markets are shooting up.
The first step in managing this situation is to acknowledge that you are not different from others and could be getting impacted in the same manner. If you don’t acknowledge the problem, then there is nothing to resolve.
I typically remind myself of these points when faced with rapidly rising or crashing markets
Cannot predict markets
I cannot predict the markets. Period! I cannot divine the future and care two hoots if others can or cannot. If that is the case, then my decisions are based on what I know as of today and not what may or may not happen. As a result, I have lesser tendency to beat myself up for a decision at a later date.
The next logical point is that the future may prove me right or wrong. However if I make rational and intelligent decisions, luck evens out and I should do fairly well. Till date, I have seen that happen.
I try to note down my thoughts and reasoning when buying or selling a stock. This helps me in checking back on my thought process at a later date.
Cooling period
I have also accepted the fact that I am like everyone else – nothing special. So I will be swept by emotions from time to time. The best antidote to it is to have a cooling period when making a decision on a stock.
I start analyzing a stock and if I get too excited, I will create a small position to temper the urge or itch. I leave the analysis for a few days or weeks and will then come back to it with a fresh mind. A lot of times I have been surprised with my decision (what was I thinking!). The downside is that during a bull market, such an idea can run away from you. I think that’s an acceptable risk.
Search for negative opinion
I try to force myself to look for negative information which goes against my thesis. This helps in countering the optimisim and hopefully improves the analysis.
There are no magic bullets or set formulae in managing emotions. It comes down to our individual makeup and what works for us.
Watch list of stocks
I am analyzing the following stocks these days
Noida toll bridge
Facor alloys
HDFC bank
Patel airtemp
And a few others. The idea of analyzing these stocks is to understand the business and calculate their fair value. I have been building a list of ideas with my estimates of fair value. Most, or almost all the stocks are not in my buy range. However it is important to analyze these stocks in advance, so that when the opportunity comes, one can move fast and create a decent size position
Replying to a comment, a correction and misc thoughts
I got the following comment recently
If I take u back to 1994, how would u have spotted Infosys. The only way one could spot it could be through the market opportunity, good results and good management.or u may enlighten if there was any other way. So it could have been a kind of recurring deposit wherein one wud have seen good results and put money in that company every quarter.
I agree there could have been companies where the growth wud have stopped, but then its like finding out 20 horses in a race of 5000 and then slowly and steadily identifying the best horse through results only. When I say results I mean higher EPS also and not just a company like Teledata or any other which diluted its equity too.
Thats what big companies like GE, Tatas do. Hire gud people and then thru performance weed out the non performers.
Agreed that Educomp is richly valued or investing in Infosys in 2000 wud have been burning fingers. What I am saying is that implmenting the value investing approach with growth companies.Take micro technologies for instance. It has been growing at CAGR of >50% for last 4 years. It has a book value of 206 approx. It trades at 220. EPS of around 50. Almost no debt. Mcap of 60% CAGR for last few years.
These companies are not richly valued at all.Thru Value Investing combined with Growth, I could see huge returns. Unfortunately I did not put a lot for money. e.g Rajesh Exports in a single year increased its sales from 200 to 2200 crore somewhere around 2003. That time the stock did not appreciate and had excellent value(128 book value, eps around 40, Price around 150. It gave 25 times returns since then), That was the time to enter and make huge money. and I did but with a small amount as I was learning then.
Following is my response :
Hi anonymous
There is a book, The gorrila game, which talks about an approach on how to invest in tech companies.
Approach is similar to the one you mention ..buy the whole basket ..and then follow the results of each. sell the poor performers and invest the cash into the good performers. That could have been a way to make money in infosys.
However it would have been diffcult to have the foresight in 1994 that infosys would do so well.even employees working in infosys did not recognise that (employees who were given options then thought the options were worthless).
I think growth is compatible with valueinvesting. Growth in the end, is a variable in the valuation process. As long as your are paying less than the growth implied intrinsic value, you will do well. So microtechnologies and Geodesic may fall in that bucket. They maybe insanely undervalued due to the excellent prospects. I have however not looked at these companies and hence cannot comment. However I would definitely look at them now.
Regarding your experience with rajesh exports, I can understand what happened as I have gone through similar experiences several times – namely how do you know beforehand that you are right on a company. I think as one gains experience, one learns to identify and benefit from such opporunities.
A correction
In the valuation of several companies I have used the following formulae to check the valuation
Mcap – cash on hand = Net Mcap
Net Mcap / Net profit = effective PE.
There is an error in the above approach. Typically the above cash earns 8-10% as part of the other income. The net profit should be adjusted with this non core income to arrive at the effective PE, otherwise you end up double counting the cash.
The error, lucklily has not changed most of the valuations I have done, but it is an error all the same and has a bigger impact if the cash as a % of market cap (mcap) is high. It is such an obvious error, but I have missed it till now. Well, better late than never.
A quote
I saw this quote from Keynes (A famous economist)
When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?
Reply to a criticism during the Great Depression of having changed his position on monetary policy, as quoted in Lost Prophets: An Insider’s History of the Modern Eonomists (1994) by Alfred L. Malabre, p. 220
This quote is very apt in investing. One analyses companies based on present facts and a set of assumptions. Valuation is finally an exercise of projecting the future. By being conservative, you can reduce the possiblity of an error. However when facts change dramatically, I am reminded of the above quote and find it prudent to change my mind – nothing wrong with that. Even a 60-70% success rate in picking stocks (being right 6-7 times out of 10) can give very good results in the long run.
Misc thoughts
I am reading through the Annual reports of several companies which I follow. I will be posting my analysis on the same. The market seems to be going one step forward and one step back. There are problems developing in the US and the markets may start weakening in the US. In india, inflation seems to be high and somehow the policy response has still not been strong enough. I think the RBI thinks that this inflation is temporary and it will cool on its own.
I hope they are right for everyone’s sake. If however they are wrong and they forced to hike the rates further to kill inflation, then we could have nasty times ahead of us in the market.